Which Former PEOPLE's Sexiest Man Alive You're Most Compatible with, Based on Your Zodiac Sign

See which former SMA aligns best with your zodiac sign, according to astrologer Valerie Mesa's readings

It's that time of year again!

PEOPLE's 2024 Sexiest Man Alive reveal is almost here, so in honor of the highly-anticipated event, we're looking back in the vault of past title holders to see which lucky recipients best align with you.

Celebrity astrologer Valerie Mesa helped with the task, which wasn't easy given only 12 zodiac signs and a slew of sexy men who've held the coveted title over the course of nearly four decades. Since 1985, 34 celebrities have been selected with Mel Gibson being the first.

In fact, there have been a few double-up stars who've been honored with the SMA title twice to date: Brad Pitt (who won in 1995 and 2000), George Clooney (who won in 1997 and 2006 ) Johnny Depp(who won in 2003 and 2009) and Richard Gere (who won in 1993 and 1999).

Former title holders have spanned a variety of genres across sports and entertainment. However, there have only been five honorees who weren't actors: John F. Kennedy Jr., Adam Levine, David Beckham, Blake Shelton and John Legend.

While there clearly hasn't been a shortage of actors, onscreen doctors have been another trend in recent years. In fact, the most recent person to wear the crown — PEOPLE's 2024 Sexiest Man Alive Patrick Dempsey — became the 15th onscreen actor to hold the title.

Now, read on for which former PEOPLE's Sexiest Man Alive aligns best with you, according to your zodiac sign!

Related: George Clooney Shares His Advice for PEOPLE's Sexiest Man Alive: 'There's a Lot of Responsibility' (Exclusive)

Aries (March 21 to April 19)

Aries, you match with Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson!

Since your zodiac sign is governed by Mars, Mesa says you "thrive on physical challenges and adrenaline-fueled adventures." She says the actor's "determined and steadfast Taurus sun" is "just what Aries needs" to complete their fitness goals and fuel some healthy competition.

Taurus (April 20 to May 20)

Taurus, you match with Chris Hemsworth!

Mesa says the MCU star's "radiant Leo sun" and "grounded Virgo moon, Mercury and Venus" is what makes his alignment with your zodiac sign so "perfect." Plus, there are several characteristics that add to it, too.

"The actor's charismatic nature attracts this Venus-ruled sign," says Mesa, noting that Tauruses value "stability and sensuality." His "meticulous" Virgo traits, meanwhile, is what she says "would assure every romantic outing is thoughtfully planned."

Related: Venus in Sagittarius Square Neptune in Pisces Creates Unrealistic Expectations

Gemini (May 21 to June 20)

Gemini, you match with Matthew McConaughey!

The Oscar winner has a "smoldering Scorpio sun and curious Gemini rising," which Mesa says would be "a pretty epic match" with your Air sign. "Together, they would thrive on mentally stimulating conversations, keeping both partners engaged and inspired," Mesa adds.

McConaughey also has Venus conjunct Jupiter in Libra, which Mesa says embodies "a sociable and magnetic personality," which immediately draws Gemini in.

Cancer (June 21 to July 22)

Cancer sign, you match with Patrick Dempsey!

Mesa says the reigning PEOPLE's Sexiest Man Alive is a "handsome Capricorn with McDreamy (Libra moon) eyes" who would be "an ideal match" for a "hopeless-romantic Cancer." She explains, "This Water sign longs for a partner who is reliable and grounded."

For example, Mesa says this is ideally someone they can "build a cozy home with" and "also nurture after a long day at the office — or on set!"

Leo (July 23 to Aug. 22)

Leo, you match with Michael B. Jordan!

This zodiac sign is known for its "confidence, warmth and flair for drama," says Mesa. The Black Panther actor is an "intellectual Aquarius" known for his "sparkling wit" and "good looks," which she says would "easily capture" a Leo sign's attention.

Leos love to be entertained. Mesa says Jordan's "cerebral nature" as an Air sign "would know just how to shower this Fire sign with affection and praise."

Virgo (Aug. 23 to Sept. 22)

Virgo, you match with Ryan Reynolds!

With his "intriguing Scorpio stellium" and "meticulous Virgo rising," Mesa says the Deadpool star would make "a natural match" for this zodiac sign. Makes sense given his marriage to Blake Lively, who is a Virgo herself!

Mesa points out that their sweet relationship "proves" Reynolds "affinity for the Earth sign's qualities. "This pairing is the perfect combination of passion and precision," she says.

Related: Which Ryan Reynolds Character Is Your Best Match, Based on Your Zodiac Sign

Libra (Sept. 23 to Oct. 22)

Libra, you match with Chris Evans!

The Ghosted actor is a "curious Gemini" with a "mischievous twinkle in his eyes," says Mesa, noting that this sign would "naturally radiate" towards his "quick-witted and playful nature." She points out that Libra, a Venus-ruled sign, also "thrives on beauty and all things aesthetically pleasing."

As a result, Mesa says these two would be "undoubtedly captivated" by each other.

Scorpio (Oct. 23 to Nov. 21)

Scorpio, you match with George Clooney!

Mesa says this "cosmic pairing" makes for a "profound and enduring love story" due to Scorpio's intensity combined with the "reliability" trait that the two-time Sexiest Man Alive recipient's Taurus sign processes.

Clooney's "dependable Taurus energy" can provide the "stability and loyalty that this Water sign craves," she explains. "This is a Mars and Venus meet cute!"

Sagittarius (Nov. 22 to Dec. 21)

Sagittarius, you match with Paul Rudd!

This zodiac sign is known for its "love of freedom and a good laugh," says Mesa, noting that these traits "fit the bill perfectly" with the Ant-Man actor's Aries stellium with a Mars in Sagittarius.

"He brings a playful, spirited energy to the function," she explains, "which is exactly what this Fire sign craves in a partner."

Related: Which Elf Character You Are, Based on Your Zodiac Sign

Capricorn (Dec. 22 to Jan. 19)

Capricorn, you match with Idris Elba!

The Golden Globe winner was born with "a down-to-earth Virgo stellium and his North Node of Destiny in Capricorn," says Mesa, noting that his "methodical mind and hardworking approach would naturally resonate with this Cardinal Earth sign."

She adds, "Together, they'd create a partnership grounded in shared values, resulting in a love that is equally ambitious and fulfilling."

Aquarius (Jan. 20 to Feb. 18)

Aquarius, you match with Channing Tatum!

"Born with a sensual Taurus sun and a playful Venus in Gemini, the Magic Mike star would bring an element of mischief, flirtation and intellectual curiosity to Aquarius' life," says Mesa. "His ability to think outside the box would instantly captivate this Air sign."

Pisces (Feb. 19 to March 20)

Pisces, you match with John Legend!

"With his strong Capricorn influence and sensual Venus in Scorpio, dreamy Pisces would find an ideal match in this Grammy winner," says Mesa. "His grounded nature would provide the stability this Water sign craves, as well as an element of intensity and passion, which Pisces finds irresistible."